Peak Avg = average Win Share value of top 3 WS seasons BaseCamp = 60% of Peak Average, to be used as a measure of consistency TOT_WS_PK = Total Win Shares by player above BaseCamp in a single season TOT_WS_SEAS = Total seasons by player with win shares above BaseCamp Data through 2007 season. nameFirst nameLast finalGame PeakAvg BaseCamp TOT_WS_PK TOT_WS_SEAS 1 Hank Aaron 10/3/1976 39 23.4 164.2 17 2 Babe Ruth 5/30/1935 53 31.8 162 15 3 Willie Mays 9/9/1973 42 25.2 161 15 4 Cy Young 42.67 25.6 147.4 16 5 Ty Cobb 9/11/1928 47 28.2 143.4 13 6 Lou Gehrig 4/30/1939 42.33 25.4 141.2 12 7 Mel Ott 7/11/1947 36.67 22 134 16 8 Barry Bonds 52 31.2 128.4 13 9 Stan Musial 9/29/1963 43.33 26 127 13 10 Eddie Collins 8/2/1930 42 25.2 125.8 11 11 Kid Nichols 45 27 125 11 12 Honus Wagner 50.33 30.2 123.8 11 13 Mike Schmidt 5/28/1989 37.67 22.6 122.6 14 14 Rogers Hornsby 7/20/1937 43.33 26 121 10 15 Tris Speaker 8/30/1928 45.67 27.4 118.2 12 16 Ted Williams 9/28/1960 46.33 27.8 117.2 11 17 Pete Rose 8/17/1986 35.5 21.3 113.5 15 18 Alex Rodriguez 37.67 22.6 109.4 11 19 Eddie Mathews 9/27/1968 38 22.8 106.2 11 20 Christy Mathewson 9/4/1916 38.33 23 105 10 21 Gary Sheffield 34 20.4 103.6 11 22 Mickey Mantle 9/28/1968 49.33 29.6 103.4 11 23 Paul Waner 4/26/1945 35 21 100 12 24 Johnny Mize 9/26/1953 33.33 20 96 10 25 Fred Clarke 30.5 18.3 95.4 12 26 Joe Morgan 9/30/1984 41 24.6 95 10 27 Rickey Henderson 9/19/2003 37 22.2 94.4 13 28 Walter Johnson 9/30/1927 47.67 28.6 94 10 29 Sam Crawford 36 21.6 93.6 14 30 Paul Molitor 9/27/1998 30 18 93 13 31 Warren Spahn 10/1/1965 30.33 18.2 92 15 32 Reggie Jackson 10/4/1987 35 21 91 13 33 Billy Williams 10/2/1976 31.67 19 90 11 34 Eddie Murray 9/20/1997 31.67 19 90 15 35 Frank Robinson 9/18/1976 38.67 23.2 89.4 13 36 Arky Vaughan 9/22/1948 36.67 22 89 9 37 Al Kaline 10/2/1974 30.67 18.4 88.4 14 38 Richie Ashburn 9/30/1962 29 17.4 88.2 12 39 Joe Jackson 9/27/1920 37.67 22.6 87.8 7 40 Frank Thomas 35.67 21.4 87.6 11 41 Charlie Gehringer 9/27/1942 34 20.4 87 10 42 Wade Boggs 8/27/1999 34.33 20.6 85.6 9 43 Joe DiMaggio 9/30/1951 40 24 85 10 44 Bobby Wallace 25.33 15.2 84.6 12 45 Ken Griffey 32.33 19.4 84.6 11 46 Reggie Smith 10/3/1982 28 16.8 84.4 12 47 George Van Haltren 28.33 17 84 14 48 Roberto Clemente 10/3/1972 31.33 18.8 83.4 12 49 Chipper Jones 31.5 18.9 83.3 13 50 George Davis 30 18 83 14 51 Elmer Flick 33.33 20 83 9 52 Albert Pujols 40 24 83 7 53 Vladimir Guerrero 31 18.6 82.6 9 54 Jesse Burkett 34.33 20.6 82.6 14 55 Jimmie Foxx 9/23/1945 40.5 24.3 82.3 9 56 Earl Averill 4/25/1941 31 18.6 82 10 57 Lou Whitaker 10/1/1995 26.67 16 82 14 58 Jim Thome 31.67 19 82 11 59 Jake Beckley 21.67 13 82 17 60 Dan Brouthers 31.33 18.8 81.4 12 61 Mark McGwire 10/7/2001 33.67 20.2 81 10 62 Roger Clemens 30.5 18.3 80.4 12 63 Ed Delahanty 35.67 21.4 80.4 9 64 Max Carey 9/29/1929 28 16.8 80.4 12 65 Greg Maddux 28.5 17.1 79.8 12 66 Fred McGriff 7/15/2004 27.67 16.6 79.8 12 67 Manny Ramirez 34.5 20.7 79.6 12 68 Luke Appling 10/1/1950 32.67 19.6 79.4 11 69 Goose Goslin 9/25/1938 31 18.6 79.2 13 70 Yogi Berra 5/9/1965 33 19.8 79.2 11 71 Jeff Bagwell 36.67 22 79 13 72 Minnie Minoso 10/5/1980 30 18 79 11 73 Dave Winfield 10/1/1995 30.67 18.4 78.2 12 74 Lefty Grove 9/28/1941 37.33 22.4 78.2 12 75 George Brett 10/3/1993 36.5 21.9 78.1 11 76 Brooks Robinson 8/13/1977 28.67 17.2 77.6 12 77 Dick Allen 6/19/1977 38.67 23.2 77.4 8 78 Nap Lajoie 43.33 26 77 8 79 Pete Alexander 5/28/1930 42.33 25.4 77 10 80 Craig Biggio 36.5 21.9 76.9 9 81 Keith Hernandez 7/24/1990 30.33 18.2 76.8 11 82 Hank Greenberg 9/18/1947 33.67 20.2 76.6 7 83 Willie McCovey 7/6/1980 35.67 21.4 76.4 9 84 Jim Palmer 5/12/1984 29.33 17.6 76 10 85 Bill Dahlen 30 18 76 13 86 Billy Hamilton 34.5 20.7 76 10 87 Willie Davis 9/30/1979 26 15.6 75.8 12 88 Jimmy Wynn 9/27/1977 33.33 20 75 8 89 Bert Blyleven 10/4/1992 25 15 75 13 90 Al Oliver 10/5/1985 25 15 75 11 91 Roy Thomas 29.67 17.8 74 10 92 Zack Wheat 9/21/1927 31.67 19 74 10 93 Mickey Cochrane 5/25/1937 29.67 17.8 73.8 9 94 Bobby Abreu 33 19.8 73.8 9 95 Eddie Plank 8/6/1917 31 18.6 73.4 11 96 Derek Jeter 32 19.2 73.2 9 97 Rafael Palmeiro 30.67 18.4 73.2 12 98 Mark Grace 9/28/2003 25.67 15.4 72.8 13 99 Barry Larkin 10/3/2004 31 18.6 72.6 9 100 Ben Chapman 5/12/1946 22.33 13.4 72.6 11 101 Luis Aparicio 9/28/1973 21.5 12.9 72.5 15 102 Joe Cronin 4/19/1945 34 20.4 72.4 9 103 Gary Carter 9/27/1992 32 19.2 72.2 9 104 Amos Rusie 45.67 27.4 72.2 7 105 Tony Fernandez 10/7/2001 25 15 72 11 106 Brett Butler 9/28/1997 26.67 16 72 11 107 Bobby Doerr 9/7/1951 27 16.2 72 10 108 Bobby Bonds 10/4/1981 32 19.2 72 10 109 Lou Brock 9/30/1979 30.33 18.2 71.8 11 110 Willie Randolph 10/4/1992 25.67 15.4 71.2 12 111 Dale Murphy 5/21/1993 32.33 19.4 71.2 7 112 Edgar Martinez 10/3/2004 29 17.4 71 10 113 Bobby Grich 10/2/1986 30.67 18.4 70.6 11 114 Rusty Staub 10/6/1985 31 18.6 70.2 8 115 Harry Heilmann 5/31/1932 33.5 20.1 70.1 9 116 Al Simmons 7/1/1944 36 21.6 70 10 117 Harmon Killebrew 9/26/1975 35 21 70 11 118 Todd Helton 31.33 18.8 69.8 9 119 Kenny Lofton 24 14.4 69.8 13 120 Duke Snider 10/3/1964 37.33 22.4 69.8 8 121 Joe Judge 5/12/1934 21 12.6 69.6 14 122 Tom Seaver 9/19/1986 31 18.6 69.4 11 123 Brian Giles 32 19.2 69.4 8 124 Andre Dawson 9/29/1996 27.67 16.6 69.4 11 125 Pee Wee Reese 9/26/1958 29.5 17.7 69.3 11 126 Tom Glavine 22.67 13.6 69.2 13 127 Andruw Jones 28.67 17.2 69.2 9 128 Pie Traynor 8/14/1937 26.67 16 69 11 129 Wilbur Cooper 7/21/1926 28.33 17 69 10 130 Tim Raines 9/29/2002 35 21 69 7 131 Gabby Hartnett 9/24/1941 27 16.2 68.8 11 132 Robin Yount 10/3/1993 35.33 21.2 68.4 8 133 Hugh Duffy 31 18.6 68.2 8 134 Bill Terry 9/22/1936 32 19.2 68.2 9 135 Johnny Bench 9/29/1983 35 21 68 9 136 Joe Gordon 9/30/1950 28.33 17 68 9 137 Gil Hodges 5/5/1963 27 16.2 68 10 138 Ron Santo 9/29/1974 35.33 21.2 67.6 7 139 Harry Hooper 10/4/1925 26.33 15.8 67.4 12 140 Roberto Alomar 9/5/2004 35.33 21.2 67.4 8 141 Ryne Sandberg 9/28/1997 36.33 21.8 67.4 7 142 Lou Boudreau 8/24/1952 32 19.2 67.4 8 143 Jose Cruz 7/19/1988 28.67 17.2 67.2 9 144 Darrell Evans 10/1/1989 31 18.6 67 10 145 Ed Walsh 9/11/1917 41.33 24.8 67 5 146 Gus Weyhing 35 21 67 6 147 Amos Otis 8/5/1984 28.33 17 67 9 148 Sherry Magee 9/27/1919 35 21 67 7 149 Tommy Leach 30 18 67 9 150 Jimmy Sheckard 32 19.2 66.8 11